Hello Scott,
There is an easy solution to your problem.
You will need a
VGA to DVI adapter so that you can run the second VGA monitor on the DVI port.
A VGA splitter will not work. The most that will do is show the same thing on both screens.
Here is a link to the Adapter:
VGA to DVI adapterAfter you get the adpater, plug in the monitors. Then you will need to enable the extra monitor in
the Control Panel Display Settings. Here is a complete tutorial on how to enable extra monitors.
How to Setup Multiple Monitors in the Control Panel Display SettingComputers Monitors Desktops Dual Monitor Multiple Monitors Multi-Screen